Garrett Planning Network
Financial Planners
Join The Network >>

By: Catherine Hawley, CFP®, posted on 08/31/2017

How Saving for Retirement Can Help You Pay off Your Student Loans

How Saving for Retirement Can Help You Pay off Your Student Loans

If you’re dealing with student loans, it might be hard to even consider the idea of saving for retirement. When you’re paying hundreds, or even thousands, of dollars every month towards your debt, how can you possibly find extra room in your budget to invest?

It’s an understandable feeling, but there’s a hidden relationship between these two financial goals that can make it easier to accomplish both at the same time.

In fact, saving for retirement can actually reduce your student loan payments and help you pay them off even faster. Here’s how it works.


How Retirement Contributions Affect Student Loan Payments

If you’re enrolled in income-driven repayment, your monthly student loan payment depends on your income. The less you make, the less you have to pay.


The actual number used in the calculation is called your Adjusted Gross Income, or AGI. This number is calculated by adding up all the money you make during the year and subtracting out certain allowed deductions.

As it turns out, retirement contributions are among those allowed deductions. Every dollar you contribute to your 401(k) or Traditional IRA is subtracted from your gross income when calculating your AGI.

What that means is that by contributing to these retirement accounts, you reduce your income for the purposes of calculating your monthly student loan payment. And a lower income leads to a lower monthly payment.

A lower monthly payment isn’t always good. Paying less now often leads to paying more interest over time. But there are two big potential benefits:

  1. Increased flexibility. You can always choose to pay more each month, but smaller required payments give you more flexibility to adjust to whatever life throws your way.

  2. Increased forgiveness. Less money paid towards your student loans could result in more of your loans being forgiven, especially if you qualify for Public Service Loan Forgiveness. Though it’s worth noting that some people have recently had serious challenges with this program.

There is one situation in particular in which the strategy of contributing more to retirement accounts can have an especially big impact on your student loans.


The Ideal Scenario

Imagine a married couple where the husband has $200,000 in student loans and is making minimal income as a resident. The wife is debt-free and makes good money as a software engineer.



Their combined income is high, so if they file taxes jointly they may not get much relief from income-driven repayment.

But what if they instead decide to file taxes separately and max out the husband’s retirement accounts before even touching the wife’s accounts (other than taking full advantage of her 401(k) employer match)?

They would likely end up with a bigger tax bill, but they would also do the following:

  1. Significantly reduce the husband’s AGI, both because the wife’s income is no longer included and because they maxed out his tax-deductible retirement contributions.

  2. Thereby resulting in a much smaller monthly student loan payment.

  3. If he is working for a non-profit hospital, he could be on track to have much of that $200,000 in student loans forgiven, tax-free.

This is a complicated strategy with potential pitfalls and various ramifications. You should absolutely speak to a tax advisor and or financial planner who understands the ins and outs when considering this approach.

But if it’s done right, it could save you a lot of money and allow you to jump-start your retirement savings.


Student Loans Don't Have to Prevent You from Saving for Retirement

Student loans can make it hard to start saving, especially when you’re early in your career.

If you contribute to the right accounts - like your 401(k), Traditional IRA, and even a health savings account - you can lessen the burden of your student loans and get a solid start on your retirement savings. It’s a win-win.


Image from:  http://studentloanwarrior.org/2016/03/10/pay-off-student-loans-start-saving-retirement/